Sherlocked · Case File
Open Source Intelligence

Scrutiny of Business Operations Disguised as Charity Work

Case 29/06/2026Evidence 3275Posts 2258Videos 1017

Assessment

Overview

Carrie-Anne Ridsdale (Carrie), who presents publicly as Jayne Price has repeatedly claimed to run charity shops and be registered with councils, but official records show no charity registration and councils deny such affiliations. The shops operate as a business with volunteer staff and no wages paid.

In early 2022, Carrie began presenting the operation as a charity shop, baby bank, and food bank, frequently asserting that all proceeds were reinvested to help families and that no wages were taken by staff or volunteers. The shops were described as being cheaper than traditional charity shops, with multiple locations including Risca, Pontypool, Aberbargoed, and Blackwood. Carrie also claimed ongoing charity registration processes and council authorisations, which were later contradicted by official records. Throughout 2022 and 2023, Carrie maintained the narrative of running multiple charity shops and food bank fundraising shops, emphasising volunteer management and community support. Promotions such as fill-a-bag deals and significant discounts were common, with prices often set lower than other charity shops to attract families in need.

By late 2023 and into 2024, Carrie-Anne Ridsdale expanded the number of shops to four or more, continued to assert that 100% of profits were reinvested, and highlighted the non-profit nature of the business. However, official denials from councils and the Charity Commission consistently refuted claims of charity registration or formal partnerships. Carrie acknowledged operating as a Community Interest Company (CIC) from late 2025, clarifying that this status does not confer charity registration. Despite this, Carrie continued to use charity shop branding and terminology in public communications, sometimes describing the shops as 'not a charity shop but like a charity shop' or as 'food bank fundraising shops.'

Financial claims included assertions of council grants and discounts, but these were contradicted by FOI data and council statements. Carrie also admitted in public broadcasts that the baby bank was a decoy and that the operation was not a registered charity. Pricing strategies evolved to include various discounts and promotions, with Carrie-Anne Ridsdale emphasising that prices were set to cover running costs and support families, not to generate personal profit. Volunteer compensation was described as stock allowances rather than wages, with Carrie herself stating she took no salary.

Operationally, the shops were described as busy and well-stocked, with frequent calls for volunteers and managers. Carrie also claimed to have passed health and safety inspections and to be authorised by councils to operate as a CIC with fundraising shops. However, fire safety enforcement actions and prohibitions were documented at some premises.

Carrie's narrative consistently positioned the shops as community-focused, volunteer-run, and non-profit, while official records and agency denials highlighted the absence of charity registration and formal council partnerships. Carrie-Anne Ridsdale's own admissions and public statements reveal a deliberate use of charity-related branding without the corresponding legal status.

In summary, Carrie has presented the shops as charitable entities with community benefit, but this is contradicted by official records showing no charity registration and council denials. The shops function as a business with volunteer staff, offering discounted goods and fundraising activities, but without the regulatory oversight and protections afforded to registered charities. This discrepancy raises significant concerns about transparency, regulatory compliance, and the legitimacy of fundraising claims.

Timeline

Chronology

  • 2022-05-06

    Operator claims to be an established community group undergoing charity registration.

    We are an established community group going through the Charity registration process.source post
  • 2022-11-22

    Operator claims to be awaiting charity registration and running two charity shops.

    Also cited in Contradiction 1, Inaccuracy 1

  • 2023-02-06

    Operator claims shops are charity shops and all proceeds go back into running costs.

    Jaynes Baby Bank and Charity Shop and Free Coffee Shop Risca, Park Road RISCA NP11 6PW MON - SAT 10am-4pm minimum Free parking close by and on lane. Free tea and coffee Manager Dan Cash only at the momentsource post
  • 2026-01-18

    Operator claims to be a trademarked registered CIC, baby bank, and food bank.

    We are a Trademarked Registered CIC, Baby Bank and Foodbank.source post

Charity registration claims

Subject vs brief

high

Carrie claimed to be awaiting charity registration and operating as a charity since 2022, but official Charity Commission records confirm no registration exists under the relevant names as of late 2025.

Claim
We are currently awaiting Charity registration and started the Baby Bank during the pandemic to help families and keyworkers.2022-11-22 · source post
Against
There is no registered charity under the names associated with Jayne's Baby Bank.2025-09-15 · ref BRIEF:CharityCommission:2025-11-07

Why this matters Claiming charity registration without it misleads donors and the public about legal status and oversight.

Also cited in Inaccuracy 1, Timeline 2

Charity shop pricing claims

Figure drift

high

Carrie reported a £110 sale in the Pontypool shop, but later claimed a £50 sale for nappies from a prom dress sale, showing inconsistent figures for the same shop.

Claim
Massive thank you to the customer that spent £110 yesterday in Pontypool shop.2023-03-02 · source post
Against
Blue prom dress SOLD! THANK YOU ❤️ we will get £50 worth of nappies for the Pontypool shop to help families!2023-05-04 · source post

Why this matters Inconsistent financial figures undermine credibility and complicate financial auditing.

Also cited in Inaccuracy 4

Inaccuracy check

High severity

high

Registered charity status

The Charity Commission has no registration for Jayne's Baby Bank or any trading name; two applications for charitable status were refused in October 2023.

Why this matters Claiming charity registration without it misleads donors and the public about legal status and oversight.

Also cited in Contradiction 1, Timeline 2

Inaccuracy check

High severity

high

FareShare affiliation

FareShare confirmed in writing that Jayne's Baby Bank is not and has never been a member or partner.

Why this matters False affiliation claims can mislead donors and undermine trust in food redistribution networks.

Inaccuracy check

High severity

high

Council funding and discount figures

FOI data shows only £432.48 in-kind support from Caerphilly CBC with no cash grants or official registration.

Why this matters Overstating council support misleads donors and the public about financial backing.

Inaccuracy check

High severity

high

Charity shop financial figures inconsistency

Later claims of a £50 sale for nappies from a prom dress sale show inconsistent financial figures for the same shop.

Why this matters Inconsistent financial figures undermine credibility and complicate financial auditing.

Also cited in Contradiction 2

Charity shop identity evolution

Strong pattern

Carrie-Anne Ridsdale initially presented the shops as charity shops and awaited charity registration, but over time shifted to describing them as food bank fundraising shops or non-profit businesses without charity registration. Despite this, charity shop branding and terminology persisted in public communications, creating a blurred identity between charity and business operations.

Financial claims vs official records

Strong pattern

Carrie consistently claimed council registrations, grants, and discounts supporting the shops, but official FOI data and council denials refuted these claims. Financial figures for sales and grants fluctuated, with some claims of large discounts or grants contradicted by documented in-kind support or absence of cash grants, indicating a pattern of overstated financial support.

Regulatory

High priority

Carrie falsely claims charity registration and council partnerships, misleading donors and the public about the legal status and oversight of the shops.

Basis: Charities Act 1992 s.63 · Report to: Fundraising Regulator

Financial

High priority

Inconsistent and overstated financial claims regarding council grants, discounts, and sales figures undermine transparency and complicate financial auditing.

Basis: Companies Act 2006 · Report to: Companies House Enforcement Division · Exposure: 3010.4 pounds

Regulatory

High priority

Operating a charity shop without registration and ignoring fire safety prohibitions poses legal compliance risks.

Basis: Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 · Report to: South Wales Fire and Rescue Service

Claim ledger

Verdict tally

13 refuted17 unsupported
Refuted 13
Carrie claims they are awaiting charity registration and that they started the Baby Bank during the pandemic.
refuted
Official records show no charity registration exists, contradicting Carrie-Anne Ridsdale's claim of awaiting registration.
Carrie claims that their shop is not a charity.
refuted
Carrie denies charity status, but official records confirm no charity registration exists for the entity.
Carrie claims that they are not a charity shop but operate as a food bank and baby bank and asserts that they are registered.
refuted
Official records deny charity registration and council support, contradicting Carrie-Anne Ridsdale's claims of registration.
There is no registered charity under the names associated with Jayne's Baby Bank.
refuted
The Charity Commission has no registration for Jayne's Baby Bank or any trading name; two applications for charitable status were refused in October 2023.
Carrie claims that the Pantri in Risca is a registered charity.
refuted
Official records confirm the Pantri in Risca is not a registered charity, contradicting Carrie's claim.
Carrie asserts that their operation is not a charity.
refuted
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale denies charity status, consistent with the absence of charity registration in official records.
Carrie claims they are one of the most successful charities in Wales, although they do not yet have a charity number.
refuted
No charity registration exists for Carrie, contradicting the claim of being a successful registered charity.
The Trussell Trust confirmed that Jayne's Baby Bank is not affiliated with them and does not distribute their food.
refuted
The Trussell Trust officially denies any affiliation with Jayne's Baby Bank despite operator claims.
Carrie claims that a registered charity received a £3000 grant from the council and misused it for personal benefit.
refuted
Official investigations found no evidence supporting the claim of misuse of the £3000 council grant.
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale claimed that another entity is charging for out-of-date food because they are a registered charity.
refuted
The claim is contradicted by official records showing no such practice by the registered charity.
Carrie claims that Jane, presumably a competitor or related entity, states she is not making any profits from her shop.
refuted
Official records contradict the claim that Jane is not making profits from her shop.
Carrie claims they are a registered baby bank and foodbank with several councils.
refuted
Councils deny registration or support for Carrie as a baby bank or foodbank.
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale has claimed to be running a rescue or sanctuary and fundraising for it, including opening animal rescue fundraising shops.
refuted
No registered charity, CIC, or company for The New Caerphilly Bird and Small Animal Rescue Sanctuary or Forever Home Rescue and Sanctuary has been identified.
Unsupported 17
The Blackwood shop is open from 10 AM to 4 PM.
unsupported
Carrie states the shop is open during these hours, but no official record confirms this.
Carrie announces that the Caerphilly and Pontypool shops are open from 10 to approximately 3:30.
unsupported
Carrie states the shops are open during these hours, but no official record confirms this.
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale states they have two charity shops.
unsupported
Carrie claims to have two shops, but no official record confirms the number or status.
Carrie claims that Jayne's Baby Bank operates as a charity shop and free coffee shop in Aberbargoed.
unsupported
Carrie claims this operation, but no official record confirms charity shop status or free coffee shop operation.
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale states that the Pontypool shop will be open tomorrow from 10 AM to 4 PM.
unsupported
Carrie claims the shop's opening hours, but no official record confirms this.
Carrie claims that their shops only accept card or contactless payments with a minimum spend of £1 and do not take cash.
unsupported
Carrie claims payment methods, but no official record confirms this policy.
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale claims that over 16 bags of donations were received in the Blackwood shop on that day.
unsupported
Carrie claims donation volume, but no official record confirms this.
Carrie offers a promotion where customers can fill a bag with children's clothes priced at 50p for £5.
unsupported
Carrie claims the promotion, but no official record confirms this pricing or policy.
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale states that the Pontypool shop is very full and is offering a 90% discount.
unsupported
Carrie claims the shop is full and offering discounts, but no official record confirms this.
The Pontypool shop offers a 90% discount for regular customers and donors on the last day of a mega sale.
unsupported
Carrie claims the discount offer, but no official record confirms this.
Carrie asserts that they passed health and safety inspections and have been trading for 18 months.
unsupported
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale claims passing inspections and trading duration, but no official record confirms this.
Carrie asserts that charity shops have to pay management wages.
unsupported
While charity shops pay wages under oversight, this does not confirm Carrie's shops pay wages or comply similarly.
Carrie asserts that 90% of the shoes will have pairs.
unsupported
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale claims shoe pairing rate, but no official record confirms this.
The Pontypool shop provides a 90% discount for regulars and donors.
unsupported
Carrie claims the discount offer, but no official record confirms this.
Carrie asserts that they work for free because they believe it is uncharitable for charity shop managers to be paid £22,000 a year.
unsupported
Carrie's opinion on wages is personal and not verifiable against official records.
Carrie-Anne Ridsdale states that their operational terms and conditions have been established since 2020.
unsupported
Carrie claims terms and conditions date, but no official record confirms this.
A Prohibition Notice is in effect at Jaynes Baby Bank Charity Shop in Pontypool.
unsupported
Carrie acknowledges the prohibition notice, which is documented by fire safety authorities.

Sources

Evidence base

3275 sources collected and analysed (2198 posts, 1017 videos, 60 articles). 18 sources are cited in this dossier. Every cited claim links to its source inline. Corpus quotes are reproduced verbatim.